Board logo

標題: [硬件] Asus N16壞左想買router [打印本頁]
作者: LKNim    時間: 2013-9-2 19:52     標題: Asus N16壞左想買router

用緊Asus N16
係好耐之前一直用緊BB100, 某日呀媽又貪平簽多條3和記返黎
所以一直用緊tomato dual wan

最近不定時候會上唔到網, 連login 192.168.1.1都唔得, wifi都斷埋, 成隻router hang左咁
試過刷DDWRT都係同樣情況
試過加散熱都係咁, CPU降埋頻480MHz->300MHz都係咁
保養又過左

想買過隻
budget有少少彈性, 一千附近都得

要求:
Dual wan(原生或者刷ROM都冇問題)
802.11AC(Optional反正未用得著)
Gigabit lan(屋企3部腦有時會互抄file)
VPN(随左自己用, 亦會開俾朋友返大陸用)
其他(其實我對router認識唔深, 咩2.4GHz同5GHz都係知有呢樣野但唔知咩黎)


題外話, 其實如果要砌部ITX router要咩budget?

[ 本帖最後由 LKNim 於 2013-9-2 20:03 編輯 ]
作者: lctang    時間: 2013-9-2 20:52

引用:
原帖由 LKNim 於 2013-9-2 19:52 發表
用緊Asus N16
係好耐之前一直用緊BB100, 某日呀媽又貪平簽多條3和記返黎
所以一直用緊tomato dual wan

最近不定時候會上唔到網, 連login 192.168.1.1都唔得, wifi都斷埋, 成隻router hang左咁
試過刷DDWRT都係同樣 ...
ITX router 最平最慳電既PC, 但你要有3個 lan port  2 Wan + 1 Lan , 仲要加隻 Switch, 但你仲未解決到 wifi 問題
作者: ccw    時間: 2013-9-2 21:12

Dual WAN is a strength of pfsense, so it would really be the best if you don't mind the troubles.
The budget can be as low as ~$1500, depending on what you want to have,
very often an entry grade Celeron with Sandy Bridge or better micro-architecture for 1Gbps WAN, or D2500/D2700/AMD E-450 for 500Mbps or below, 4GB or more RAM,
a 4GB USB Flash drive, an lan card with Intel NIC (82574L/579V are fine)(e.g. Intel EXPI9301CT), a gigabit switch
finally a motherboard with Intel NIC (intel boards), and case+PSU. You don't need a harddisk unless you are hosting server.
You can surely use other NICs, but be aware of the compatibility with the OS, depending if you are using ClearOS/pfsense/others.
The sum shouldn't exceed $2000, and the best if you can make use of old parts. In HK the problem is only getting the suitable lan card with a reasonable price......

Dual WAN, VPN are fine for both OS.
Copying files should be very fast as long as you get a Gigabit switch.
Not sure with ClearOS, but pfsense has no support on even 802.11n owing to FreeBSD doesn't support it. But you can just add a wireless access point to get the WiFi online.

[ 本帖最後由 ccw 於 2013-9-2 21:13 編輯 ]
作者: ccw    時間: 2013-9-2 21:15

Or just get from this brand,
http://www.mikrotik.com/
Many people talking about it in HKEPC.

[ 本帖最後由 ccw 於 2013-9-2 22:02 編輯 ]
作者: patman    時間: 2013-9-2 21:50

已用450G，超難用
作者: tat0801    時間: 2013-9-2 22:01

consider APPLE airport extreme?

edit.. nodual wan..
作者: Aware    時間: 2013-9-2 22:25

引用:
原帖由 tat0801 於 2013-9-2 22:01 發表
consider APPLE airport extreme?

edit.. nodual wan..
Airport series is extreme lack of other function, OK?
作者: LKNim    時間: 2013-9-2 22:32

Must have dual wan + 1Gbps
作者: tat0801    時間: 2013-9-2 23:59     標題: 回覆 7# Aware 的帖子

then buy another ASUS..
作者: BlackBird    時間: 2013-9-3 02:03

Dual WAN要有giga throughput加平一定係x86 router

n16可以試下換cap, consumer router有問題大多與供電有關
作者: BlackBird    時間: 2013-9-3 02:23

引用:
原帖由 ccw 於 2013-9-2 21:12 發表
Dual WAN is a strength of pfsense, so it would really be the best if you don't mind the troubles.
The budget can be as low as ~$1500, depending on what you want to have,
very often an entry grade Cele ...
FreeBSD 8.1 support intel 4965/5000series wireless
作者: ccw    時間: 2013-9-3 10:50

引用:
原帖由 BlackBird 於 2013-9-3 02:23 發表

FreeBSD 8.1 support intel 4965/5000series wireless
The OS supports the hardware, but may not support 802.11n(pfsense does have 802.11g support...) afaik.
At least pfsense hasn't followed up till now(2.0.3), not sure about 2.1

update:
It seems FreeBSD is ok now, let's see pfsense's support then (hopefully in not too distant future)

[ 本帖最後由 ccw 於 2013-9-3 10:52 編輯 ]
作者: poonyc    時間: 2013-9-3 11:29

引用:
原帖由 LKNii] 於 2013-9-2 22:32 發表
Must have dual wan + 1Gbps
Dualwan 再加千兆，仲要ac

市場上真係無呢隻野

就算雙wan加千兆
好多都未必食得晒幾百mbit
有的話都可能講緊三千蚊以上。。。

我都成日想搵呢類。。。但係真係無。。。一係就好貴。。。
你唔好睇vigor個的好似有。。
我用緊隻2920n
係有千兆，係有dualwan
但係開dualwan得20mb。。。。
我有pccw 同hkbn100m。。。
咁不如唔好用。。。單行仲快。。

所以要用盡真係得pc router

[ 本帖最後由 poonyc 於 2013-9-3 14:15 編輯 ]
作者: lctang    時間: 2013-9-3 14:37

比塊板你做 Ref.

自己淘...

http://www.yueson.com.cn/index.php?act=pShow&id=24
作者: qcmadness    時間: 2013-9-3 15:49

引用:
原帖由 LKNim 於 2013-9-2 22:32 發表
Must have dual wan + 1Gbps
$1500 up
作者: 刺青    時間: 2013-9-3 17:23

dual wan +802.11ac 一件頭真係無見過 ...
PC router + 張 802.11ac adapter 吧 ..
作者: LKNim    時間: 2013-9-3 18:50

其實係咪我表達得唔好呢
1Gbps係指PC<->PC
Dual wan係因為兩間ISP, 分别都係100Mbps
要$1500+?

好似如果我會刷ROM, 都係買過隻N16又或者試下換cap算數

我係DDWRT個網睇好似都唔少人用AC66U
呢隻大家有咩評價?
作者: lctang    時間: 2013-9-3 18:58

DDwrt 邊部有rom 就買個部
作者: ccw    時間: 2013-9-4 00:44

引用:
原帖由 LKNim 於 2013-9-3 18:50 發表
其實係咪我表達得唔好呢
1Gbps係指PCPC
Dual wan係因為兩間ISP, 分别都係100Mbps
要$1500+?

好似如果我會刷ROM, 都係買過隻N16又或者試下換cap算數

我係DDWRT個網睇好似都唔少人用AC66U
呢隻大家有咩評價? ...
1Gbps between PCs, you can get a 100Mbps router, then connect the pcs through a 1Gbps switch, then the switch to router, it should just work.

[ 本帖最後由 ccw 於 2013-9-4 00:46 編輯 ]
作者: poonyc    時間: 2013-9-4 10:50

引用:
原帖由 ccw 於 2013-9-4 00:44 發表


1Gbps between PCs, you can get a 100Mbps router, then connect the pcs through a 1Gbps switch, then the switch to router, it should just work.
呢家O的GIGABIT ROUTER 都唔平啦~~

DUALWAN 係好高級既野~
要求都好高~
OFFICIAL 有DUALWAN 既ROUTER 從來都唔平~
作者: ccw    時間: 2013-9-4 22:28

引用:
原帖由 poonyc 於 2013-9-4 10:50 發表

呢家O的GIGABIT ROUTER 都唔平啦~~

DUALWAN 係好高級既野~
要求都好高~
OFFICIAL 有DUALWAN 既ROUTER 從來都唔平~
So pfsense is what I prefer.



歡迎光臨 HKSpot (https://bbs.hk-spot.com/) Powered by Discuz! 6.0 Lite